Skip to content

RESP vs rental property vs life insurance for education

There’s more than one way to pay for your child’s education. An RESP gives you government grants and tax-sheltered growth. A rental property can build much more wealth, but needs more money, work and risk. Permanent life insurance combines protection with tax-advantaged cash value. For most families the RESP comes first, for the grants, and the other two are worth considering once it’s on track.

Book a consultation

Side by side

RESPRental propertyPermanent life insurance
Government moneyGrant of 20% on the first $2,500 a year (up to $7,200 per child); Canada Learning Bond for lower incomesNoneNone
Tax on growthSheltered; grants and growth are taxed as the student’s income, often at a low rateRental income taxed yearly; half of a capital gain taxed on saleGrows without annual tax in an exempt policy; withdrawals can be taxable
Money neededAs little as you likeA down payment, closing costs and a reserveRegular premiums, usually for many years
Work involvedVery littleTenants, repairs, vacanciesVery little
RiskDepends on the investments chosenLeverage, interest rates, vacancies, local market at the time you sellPolicy performance; slow cash value growth early on
ExtrasContributions come back tax-free if not used for schoolCan keep growing after school is paid forLife insurance coverage the whole time
Limits$50,000 lifetime contributions per childYour borrowing capacityExempt-policy limits

The RESP: start here for the grants

Contributing $2,500 a year per child earns the maximum $500 grant each year. Over about 15 years, that adds up to the $7,200 lifetime maximum, before any investment growth. Lower- and middle-income families can get an extra grant on the first $500 contributed each year, and the Canada Learning Bond adds up to $2,000 for eligible children with no contribution required. We can open an RESP for you, invested in segregated funds, or you can open one at your bank.

The rental property: bigger potential, bigger commitment

Buying a rental when your children are young can build significant equity by the time they’re ready for school, from mortgage paydown, rent and any rise in value. When the time comes, you can sell, or refinance and keep the property. It works best for families who already have an RESP on track, have the down payment and a cash reserve, and are ready to be landlords.

  • Rental income is taxable each year; mortgage interest and expenses are deductible against it
  • On a sale, half the capital gain is taxable, and past depreciation claimed can be taxed back
  • You may not want to sell in a weak market just because tuition is due
  • Owners can use cash damming to make more of their interest deductible

Permanent life insurance: protection plus savings

A permanent policy, on a parent or on the child, builds cash value inside an exempt policy. Later, that value can be withdrawn or borrowed against to help with education costs, and the coverage protects the family along the way. Costs are front-loaded and the cash value grows slowly at first, so it suits families thinking long-term and who also want lifelong coverage. Withdrawals can be taxable, so plan how you’ll access the money.

A common combination

  1. RESP first: at least $2,500 a year per child, to collect the full grant.
  2. Protect the plan: enough life insurance that the plan survives if something happens to you.
  3. Then grow further: a rental property or permanent insurance, if your cash flow and goals support it.

Frequently asked questions

Should I open an RESP before anything else?

For most families, yes, at least enough to collect the government grant. The Canada Education Savings Grant adds 20% to the first $2,500 you contribute each year, up to $500 a year and $7,200 per child. Few other options give you an immediate 20% return.

Can a rental property really pay for university?

It can, by building equity you sell or borrow against when your child starts school, plus rental income along the way. But it takes a lot more money and work up front, the timing of a sale may not suit the market, and the gain is taxable. It’s a bigger, riskier bet than an RESP.

What happens to an RESP if my child doesn’t go to school?

Your contributions come back to you tax-free. The grants are repaid to the government. The growth can sometimes be moved to your RRSP if you have room, or taken out as income with an extra tax. You may also be able to switch to a sibling.

How does permanent life insurance fit in?

A permanent policy on a parent or child builds cash value that grows without annual tax in an exempt policy, and also provides insurance. The cash value can be accessed later for education costs, though withdrawals can be taxable and growth is slow in the early years. It’s usually a complement to an RESP, not a replacement.

Can I use more than one?

Yes, and many families do: an RESP for the grants, then a rental property or permanent insurance for longer-term goals once the RESP is on track.

Sources

Program rules and limits change. Figures were checked on the review date below; confirm current details with the source before relying on them.

Written by Kyle Hibbert, Managing Director, Mortgage Agent Level 2 and licensed life and health insurance agent.
Last reviewed

Talk it through before you decide

Book a free consultation. We look at where you are, explain your options in plain language, and you decide what happens next.

Book a consultation